I like TARTE - All Stars Amazonian Clay collectors set because it has small eyeshadow palettes - more practical. I used some of Tarte products, such as concealer, blush and setting powder - super happy with them. It is cheaper than Huda Beauty - Rose Quartz. One minus is that I don’t think the eyeshadow colors are very surprising, I feel like I already have similar one on hand.

Huda Beauty - Rose Quartz. I like the colors and that the colors are more cool toned. I heard that people like this palette.

Which one would you choose?

  • PanSL@alien.topBEnglish
    1·
    1 year ago

    Huda’s Rose Quartz. I don’t have either, but I have Rose Quartz on my wishlist and I might eventually buy it.

    I find the All Stars palettes to have a lot of repetition even within themselves. Like the middle shade of the bottom row of the Tartlette is very similar to the top right of the Maracuja Juicy one. Maybe a different finish but probably not enough to translate to looking very different once applied to the eyes. There are other similarities like that across all 3 palettes. I think there are only 2-3 distinctly different looks you can get out of that set (not counting single shadow looks).

    There are 4 browns of different intensities in the Huda and maybe not all of them are necessary but I personally don’t mind a little redundancy for transition/crease shades. I find it easier to use different shadows to get a nice fade rather than having to really blend out 1 dark colour.

    The Tarte set does come with some face products of course, and maybe that adds value to the set for you.