• 0 Posts
  • 5 Comments
Joined 11 months ago
cake
Cake day: November 14th, 2023

help-circle
  • Mandydeth@alien.topBtoMechanical KeyboardsWhat is it with HHKB?
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    11 months ago

    Standard stagger turns your left wrist outward, as you ascend the rows, which is what creates ulnar deviation.

    No, that is present at any point on Ortholinear. Here’s some random images from Youtube videos: Even with the split ortho keyboard, ulnar deviation is present. For that to be avoided with an Ortholinear board, you would have to have inhumanly narrow shoulders.

    Ortho, with proper form, does not create this condition because there is no outward stagger to the keys forcing you to chase them.

    Unless your proper form is literally sticking your arms out in front of you like a stereotypical zombie, I don’t know how one could feasibly achieve this.

    There is no “less space from key to key” with ortho.

    There absolutely is and it is easily observable.

    You, by contrast, are trying to align your wrists to the keys themselves, which is terrible form for typing. That is why you have to uncomfortably compress yourself, and/or bend your wrists outward, to align to the keyboard.

    I’ve told you nothing about how I type, so any assumptions you are making here are based on something else.


  • Mandydeth@alien.topBtoMechanical KeyboardsWhat is it with HHKB?
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    11 months ago

    The scientific term would be “ulnar deviation”.

    True ergonomics would be more along the lines of Dactyl Manuform or Corne with tenting.

    The pronation and extension of the wrists in addition to ulnar deviation is very similar on both row staggered and ortholinear boards, the main difference being that there is less space from key-to-key with ortholinear layouts, but that doesn’t mean that it is more ergonomic.

    I can’t imagine typing in a layout like the one you are currently using and having your wrists ‘perfectly straight’ unless you had incredibly narrow shoulders with your elbows tucked into your rib cage. I have fairly petite dimensions, and even for me they would be nowhere near ‘perfectly straight’.