I recently purchased Almay All-Day Intense Gel Eyeliner in four different colors: Black, Brown, Gray, and Plum. I find that I need a liner that is nice and smooth to apply, without pulling. On days when I work from the office I apply my make up at around 7:30am and when I remove it at night, 12 or so hours later, my liner looks exactly the same. I apply to my main upper lid but not under or on the water line. Hope this helps. :)

Edited to add mascara. If you want one that won’t budge, try a tubing mascara. I like Bye Bye Panda Eyes by Essence. Lasts all day and through crying…