Covergirl Perfect Point Plus if you like a dipping liner! Really black and bold and stays on really well.
Love NYX
I like the waterproof liquid eyeliner from Physicians Formula
NYX epic ink is comparable to Stila.
The brush one is far better than Stila
I like Kiko Milano’s waterproof eyeliners. I have a black that is perfect and a turquoise that I like (they have different formulas, the turquoise kinda stains my skin a bit)
It’s a Japanese brand, heroine long and curl mascara. It’s a GODSENT for my stubborn lashes. Waterproof and smudge proof.
Wet n Wild Breakup Proof Skinny Eyeliner
This one beats the NYX one for me!
I second this!!
Not drug store, but I really like the Sephora Intense Felt-Tip Liquid Waterproof Eyeliner. I always get it during the VIB sale when it’s 30% off, so it’s really affordable.
Maybelline HyperEasy waterproof
Been using this for years for wings.
Same. It’s one of the only eyeliners I can actually properly use lol
Stila is the best
Most I’ve tried have been pretty good. The Morphe one was lackluster. Currently using NYX and Colourpop ones.
Essence ink liquid liner, the waterproof one
This is the one.
Nyx epic ink. Nothing removes it easily. Not micellar water, eye makeup remover, a cleansing balm, nothing.
Essence 24 hour ink eyeliner. costs $3.99
Tubes don’t last as long as still, but in my experience it’s great and some serious value
I actually really like the Wet n Wild Breakup Proof liquid liner!