Wet and wild, maybelline too Goodluck!

Wet n Wild breakup proof

For a pencil option, Maybelline ‘Smokey’ eyeliner is great on the lash line and it smudges well but sets down and doesn’t budge after this.

Like others have said, NYX have great liquid options and I love their ‘Epic Ink Liner’ - the best drugstore option I’ve found! I would just say make sure you get the felt tip version rather than the ink pot as it has much better control :)