I’m also super fair, and the peachy (Precious Petals?) Wet and Wild one that everyone loved a few years back was too dark (what you’re calling dirty) on me. Blossom Glow worked, though it was never my favorite. If you want it intense, apply it with a finger instead of a brush.
If you’re warm toned and trying cool ones, they’ll look dusty. And cool toned with warm shades is usually kind of orangey. Do you know your undertone?
I’m also super fair, and the peachy (Precious Petals?) Wet and Wild one that everyone loved a few years back was too dark (what you’re calling dirty) on me. Blossom Glow worked, though it was never my favorite. If you want it intense, apply it with a finger instead of a brush.
If you’re warm toned and trying cool ones, they’ll look dusty. And cool toned with warm shades is usually kind of orangey. Do you know your undertone?