1·
11 months agoI have one. Absolutely love it. I have some nicer watches, as much as $4k in value, but this one is the closest to a daily driver. It’s just got a great shape and a killer dial.
Got mine from Amazon a couple years ago for around the $425 price. The stock rubber strap is surprisingly good, Seiko isn’t known for having the best straps, but this one has a great feel and is very comfortable. But I also recommend checking out a steel bracelet for it from StrapCode. They have 3-4 options designed specifically for the Samurai. The Hex one makes this watch a tank (if you like a heavy tool watch aesthetic).
It’s hard for us to say what is best for you. You said you want a ‘forever watch’ that can go formal or casual (go anywhere do anything). You’ve picked out 4 nice, but rather different options.
I note that two of the options are chronos with panda style subdials contrast. Is that an aesthetic you’re more drawn to?
1 watch is a diver. 1 is connected to racing. 1 is more colorful, and 1 is the Santos which is classic but not for everybody (personally I feel like they’re harder to dress down despite all the claims people make).
If one of these feels best to you, do it. Other advice is right, though, try them in first if you can.
…If you want alternatives to consider
A Zenith El Primero is a watch lovers chrono with an amazing history and excellent engineering, and it would compete well with that Brietling on your list, but probably dresses up a little better than the Breitling when you wear a suit. Some people don’t like the tri-color dials though.
Omega Aqua Terra is a quintessential (non-Rolex) go anywhere, do anything “sport” watch. Works for literally any occasion except maybe a royal wedding. But, versatility can often be inversely proportional to unique character, and maybe it doesn’t speak to you for that reason.