Dang, it’s funny to see how different can people view makeup. Tarte has worked great for me, I’ve got eyeshadow palletes, lashes, and a few other things and I’ve been real happy so far.

Tarte has my perfect foundation match but the formulas don’t work for me

everything tarte is so cakey and powdery and chalky on me, it’s a whole brand of flops

I tried their famous concealer, tape whatever, and could NOT make it work for me. Maybe I bought the wrong color or something but then I tried another Tarte product and it was so impressive that I can’t remember what it was to save my life and threw it away almost immediately.

Tarte products are amazing for me

Yes! Everyone around me kept raving about their concealer - it was always so so dry no matter what prep I did

I like their lip maracujá things. But they’re too pricey

I love tarte eyeshadows lol not much else

I don’t use any of their foundations or concealers but I love their maneater mascara and eye shadow palette. Bronzer is meh.

I feel this. I feel like the brand peaked in 2013-16. It was so good back then, but it’s mostly all trash now. It’s so disappointing.

I have one good pallet from them that I got as a gift years ago and I still use it today. It’s a contour/bronzer/eyeshadow thing that smells like chocolate and it’s my eyeryday go to because helps me achieve natural look without having to pull out too many pallets. But that’s about it. I tried getting an eyeshadow palette and the formula was so different than my main hoe. Maybe because it was older it was better idk.

The Tarte Maneater liquid blush is so nice.

Their new version of Shape Tape is an absolute dream for me; I believe it’s called ultra creamy? I can never get my under eyes to look good (I also have tear troughs) and this concealer does it for me. I haven’t used any other product that does it for me.

Tarte face products make me break out and I hate scented eyeshadows because sensitive skin breaks out so yeah. Tarte is useless.

I’m also unhappy because I had a terrible customer service experience. They’re completely irresponsible and I don’t trust them.

I love Tarte! But I have dry, sensitive skin. Their creaseless concealer and liquid eyeliner are the only ones that stay on properly for me, and lasts all day.

I love their blushes and concealers. The hydrating series of serum foundation, hydrocealers are so good for my dry skin. Can’t use them now because dimethicones clog my pores. Only creaseless concealer is safe to use.

Their foundation works pretty nicely for me but then again I haven’t tried any other brands

i love the level of pigment in their eyeshadows but their “double take” eyeliner SUCKS

Did like her mascara

I do absolutely love the setting spray though.

Their mascara is one of the only brands that doesn’t hurt my eyes but the brush is so terrible I don’t know if I can keep buying it.

The lip cheat is fantastic though!!!

I love their tinted brow gel

Their setting spray is magical for me. Foundation doesn’t transfer to my mask after hours of surgery. I like their lip liner. They have my truly MLBB color. Too bad they dont last long because they’re so creamy but that’s what makes them nice to use.

I just wish I understood the hype with Hollywood flawless filter… maybe it’s for people who use lighter coverage foundation? Who knows. I’ve also used the powder, and it did nothing for me. I def don’t see how it’s preferable for those with dry skin.

I’m glad I I read this, I have coveted this brand for a couple years now but haven’t been able to take the plunge and spend the money. Instead I enjoy finding & trying drugstore dupes for CT that are highly rated.

The only thing I like about them is their lipliner and lipstick.

I’d love to have an opinion on CT products but I can’t because they don’t have a foundation/concealer shade pale enough for me rip

I find her products super tacky and not worth the price tag AT ALL

I really like their potted cream eyeshadow and don’t care much for anything else

Over hyped barely average in my opinion.

Some of their eye shadows are okay but they are grossly overpriced.

Also ALL of their products run too warm toned. There is no variety

I have been disappointment by their products as well aside from the black liquid eyeliner which is my favorite.

Can’t agree with this one! I’ve gotten a lot of compliments using lip cheat love trap (I blend with pillow talk and another color make an ombré lip). Pillow talk plain is a good nude for me as well. I recently got the pillow talk liquid blush (bc I had been using the lip stick as blush) and I love the formula. Very light and hasn’t made me breakout.

Also, I love how the lipglosses look on me. The creme pot eyeshadows are lovely and this other eye shadow kit I got a lot of compliments on. I’m a fairly light make up wearer and like things to be quick and easy while still looking put together. I think Charlotte T makeup I’ve bought does that.

Only thing I don’t like is I do find the lip cheat gets dry very quickly but that may be part of what makes it last? Over time it gets harder to blend. I wouldn’t mind replacing it if I knew something was better with a color just as flattering for me. For the record I’m fair olive. Not a lot of make up is compatible with that coloring surprisingly.

Their lipliners are THE WORST I have ever used. They are soooo dry, so waxyyy, I literally hurt my lips trying to line them 😭

But I do enjoy their lipsticks, and some of their shadow palettes can be decent but still a huge hit or miss brand.

That’s too bad. I have 1 Revolution palette and its pretty good. Not great but its decent. I wouldn’t repurchase that particular palette but I wouldn’t say no to buying another in the future.

Most of that brand sucks, but I do love their conceal and hydrate concealer.

I had one of their UD Naked palette dupes 7 years back and I really liked it! Enough that I went looking for it a few years ago and was disappointed when I couldn’t find it. I had a coworker ask me if I was wearing Modern Renaissance when I had it on lol.

It was a pretty good palette for a beginner. All nudes/pinks and a mix of mattes/shimmers. I def had to use eyeshadow primer, but it blended well. Wouldn’t rebuy it now that I’ve tried better (and more expensive) formulas, but for someone who’d only had experience with drugstore formulas and random free Lancôme / Estée Lauder palettes from my mom, it was good.

They’re baking powder is 🔥🔥

Agreed! I feel like I’m going crazy when people say the shadows are good. They’ve all been duds for me

The only thing I’ve tried from them is a concealer and I actually really enjoyed it! Gave me perfect skin texture and coverage was amazing and lasted all day. Back then I really wanted their chocolate palettes but never got the chance to. Seeing all these comments made me feel glad I never got one:))

Same! I’ve tried at least a dozen palettes and they all pretty much suck! To the person who asked which ones, I’ve gotten rid of most of them, but still have the Aristocats palette (the Duchess highlighter I do actually use) and Beautiful Darkness; and I specifically remember a couple of the Reloadeds, and Rose Gold Chocolate that I hated. 😔

I felt the same but then heard people raving about their cream bronzer so I got that to try and actually really love it! But that’s the only thing 😂

They used to be ok 6 or so years ago but now they are just awful

I have 2 of their palletes from Marshall’s. One is really really good and the other is really really not good.

i can agree the concealer was bad and not blendable at all. idk how anyone can put that under their eye comfortably

The only thing I like from them is their brow soap

EXACTLY. their most hyped products are completely crappy

Their foundation is my holy grail

Years ago I had to return a Revolution eyeshadow palette because it was irritating my skin, first time I bought that brand and the last

I’ve only tried their limited edition Simpsons setting spray and it was so good 😩

I do love their loose banana powder, but that is probably super easy to make

I dislike most things revolution but I lucked out with the most gorgeous eye palette for $10.

Agree. I don’t think they’re bad, but they aren’t up to par in comparison to other products

I’m not a huge fan of Makeup Revolution either. Their eyeliner smears and leaves me like a raccoon so fast. However, I do like the IRL Soft Focus 2 in 1 Translucent powder. It’s really fine and nice for under eyes.

I have a Revolution palette (black/gray colour book) and it’s quite patchy and doesn’t last very long. However I have another palette by them (some kind of coffee themed one) and the eyeshadows are SO pigmented and blend super well… I feel like it’s a brand that’s hard to generalise as their products are either hit or miss for me.

I had the Revolution palette and it was very grainy and hard to get pigmentation to come out , I have to scratch with the end of the brush to get something and even then it’ll just fall to my cheeks!! OMG

I actually really love their conceal and define concealer, and their powder contour

everything else i didn’t like

Revolution makes good setting sprays, I love their Sport Fix

The cream bronzer is the only thing that isn’t traaaash

I love their eyeshadows and blushes!

I have a blush palette from them that works well for me. :)

The banana powder is good tho!!

I really love their cream bronzer, feel like it’s a good dupe for the Chanel tan soleil

dang, i love the IRL filter line of products & their base fix setting spray and the pink aerosol setting spray were my faves! and their pro foundation sticks are great too! idk if i just lucked out and caught them in an upswing bc i can no longer find the pink aerosol spray or the foundation sticks.

Dang it I have a pallet buy them that I absolutely adore

Agree. I bought a contour pallette it was garbage.

Everything ive ever got from revolution has been exceptional

I bought their waterproof Big Lash mascara and it’s the only thing I’ve ever bought from them. It actually looks great, but it is NOT waterproof by the longest shot!

Literally- I work at ulta (a large makeup retailer) and can’t stand revolution. I don’t recommend it to anyone

I’m surprised you say that, I have two palettes and find them very good!

Loveeee base products and mascaras from cover girl. I’ve seen a lip gloss from them went viral on tiktok as well!!

Agree 100%. It was fine for high school but I’m glad I’ve come along way from then 🫣😬 the pictures are pure cringe

I used to love their matte primer but now it breaks me out like crazy with huge zits that never gets a head. I was wondering what was causing it. I ran out and I’m using another one and now my skin has improved so much. It makes me sad because I do like how it works, it just breaks me out so bad.

The scandalous mascara by rimmel in the bright orange tube is my HG and people are always asking me about my lashes

Cover girl foundation gave me hives lol too scared to even touch another product of theirs

Rimmel has a lot of misses but some of their liners and lipsticks are fab for the price

I used to love their brown mascara… I should look it up again, as that was ages ago

Rimmel foundation has never worked for me, I tried it a few times in the years before I could afford Mac and it was never even and always very dry and cakey. Nothing I’ve tried from covergirl was any good.

I’ll second cover girl. I’ve always had trouble with it.

Cover Girl foundation is still the only foundation that looks decent on me and I have tried a dozen different brands.

the cover girl concealer is so good

Seconding this and adding Almay

Rimmel stay glossy lip glosses are the only glosses that don’t feel like sticky glue or taste gross on my lips.

Same! I tried so many Rimmel products and never found one I even halfway liked

Mac lipsticks are so pretty but dry my lips out soooo bad.

I like L’Oreal. I’m with you on the rest.

yesss the scents make me sick

100% and also the packaging is ugly as shit

I remember trying a few of their products when they first came out. They were hyped as being hypoallergenic. They were poor quality and still made my skin itch.

My favorite blush every was by them. I was just thinking about it earlier today. It was chocolate scented and it was beautiful, with a heart stamped into it, and the case was red with a little high heel. I don’t think it’s sold anymore. What a shame

Weirdly around 2008 they had the most amazing foundation I have ever used, it had a brush applicator straight on the tube, nobody ever remembers it and I feel like maybe I imagined it

ITS THE WORST!!

Well, what about their highlighters then? I also like their “healthy velvet lipstick” line of products

I have a sample size of the butter bronzer that I got as part of a sample pack and it has no smell. I actually really like it and the color is nice on my skin, but I don’t think I could use it if it had a strong scent.

The eyeliner is great. I’m using. Easily washed off. Doesn’t smudge after I set with loose powder

Physician’s Formula is one of the few brands I buy consistently. I like the fragrances though and the colors are fine for me.

Everyone hyped up their eyeliner pen so much i was so excited to try it and it’s terrible for me 😭 it was streaky and didn’t stay on. I got it in black and brown and they both performed the same way

WHY ARE THEY SO ORANGE. WHY. I loved their lil ombre shiny eyeshadow palette when I was in middle school and actually recently re-bought it (because *nostalgia*) to use as a body-shimmer for halloween and I loved that little walk through memory lane but their foundation and concealer are just horrific.

This is my answer too. Such horribly fragranced products that always broke me out.

I loved their eyeshadow pallets when I was younger. They had ones for bringing out your eye color and I wore those everyday until I was able to afford higher end ones.

I actually love their eyeshadows. I have a tried so many brands but something about their eyeshadows work on my weird eyelid skin.

I have to say that Too Faced makes the best eyeshadows in the game.l

They are the MOST orange yellow company good grief. I feel like all of their base products are for Simpsons characters.

Okay I hate their blushes but the heart packaging is too darling lol. I love their mascaras but there are just so many better products on the market. I think the branding is just shock-factor and sell for the “scandal” of the names, the product itself just doesn’t deliver

I LOVE their born this way foundation, all time perfect color match for me. Also their lip plumper. But those are the only products I’ve used by them

The only good thing is the lip injection original.

I just said this! Too faced is terrible!

two faced has so many good products but people always assume there bad cuz their packaging is cutesy, their setting spray is the only one that works for me, their bronzer is top tier and born this way concealer is like amazing. but their foundation sucks and their eyeshadows seem chalky

I tried the foundation it’s not bad I wouldn’t say I reach for it.

Agreed. I bought a palette and a brush set a few years ago and they were both complete trash. I actually returned them and I typically am too lazy to return anything.

I was gifted a lip liner and under eye powder from that brand that were fine. The other items were bland af. Elf or wet n wild type

I’ve never been drawn to their products at all but my friend does a full face with their products and it looks amazing on her. Before I found out I had no good will towards the brand.

All their foundations pill on me and separate BADLY